Trump Regret

I just finished teaching a night class at a local university. The five week course covers United States and Nevada political and constitutional history.

During our first meeting in July, we covered the Constitutional Convention and some basic aspects of the American founding. This time, we discussed the electoral college a bit more than usual. We looked at how it works and why it was put into the Constitution. We also looked at the Electoral College map and how it plays into the 2016 Electoral College.

During that discussion, I mentioned that the Democrats hold an advantage in the Electoral College game. This is partially due to demographic shifts and a variety of political realignments that have taken place on the last 50 years.

In particular, I mentioned, Donald Trump seemed to particularly alienate the very groups that Republicans would need to appeal to (to some degree) for them to repeat the narrow Electoral College victories of George W. Bush. Such demographic groups include suburban women, Hispanics, and middle-class professionals.

One male student emailed me after class. He disagreed with my assessment. He was convinced that the anti-mining, anti-fracking, and anti-coal positions of Hillary Clinton would swing states like Pennsylvania and Ohio. He was confident that Trump would overwhelm Clinton and win in November. 

In many ways, this student was sounding a lot like my liberal friends who were all doom and gloom about Trump winning back in mid-July. Now the numbers never supported either perspective, but they were related.

That was July 12. Jump ahead to our last class on August 9.

This student was downright dejected last night.

In many ways this student fit the Trump mold. He has a very masculine few of world. “Make America Great” appealed to him as a veteran (a fairly high percentage of my students are veterans and their military experience seems to influence each one differently). This student was very concerned about sexual predators using bathroom laws to target his daughter. He is convinced that Hillary Clinton is crooked to the core.

On August 9, this student no longer thinks Trump is going to win. He thinks Trump is an absolute disaster. He thought Trump’s dominance in the Republican primaries was a sign that Trump would perform well in the general election. He hoped Trump’s economics address would be a shift…but it is just more of the same.

He said he might vote for Johnson. Or maybe he will just stay home.

Many of my Republican friends fall in the “Never Trump” camp. This guy caucused for Trump and viewed efforts to block Trump at the Republican Conventions as an insult to regular voters like him.

I saw similar reactions in 2008 when John McCain picked Sarah Palin. However, the McCain collapse was not fully evident until October 2008. It is barely mid-August and Trump is already losing his core constituency. They see the writing on the wall.

Categories: Blog, Chris, Feature, Politics

Tagged as: , ,

5 replies »

  1. Hopefully the class is leading to a better understanding of politics which I am sure it is. After thinking in class, it appears this student is thinking beyond class as well. How I may feel about this students opinions previously or now does not matter. You are dong your job, he’s using his head.

  2. Count me as one of those middle class professional swing voters. I’m not a fan of the Clintons, but Hillary is an order of magnitude better than Trump.

    While on paper primaries seem more democratic that caucuses, you risk having the current situation where extremists hijack the elections and nominate substandard nominees. I wonder if most states still had caucuses we would have ended up with Sanders and Bush as our options, either of which would have been much more acceptable to centrist voters like me.

  3. I believe that you did your job but it isn’t anyone’s right to judge this veteran. He or she have rights to think even if you disagree with those thoughts. Not one of you can see the future and tell if this person is going to be a better President over another. From what I have seen in over 50 years, nobody has been great!!!

  4. My question is: how do Democrats have such an advantage when things like Gerrymandering exist? Is gerrymandering more prevalent/important on state/local politics?

  5. The majority political party in our nation is not the Republican or Democratic Party, but the non-voting party. I had a professor tell my class that if we didn’t vote, we should essentially be ashamed of ourselves. I didn’t feel like arguing, but I completely disagreed with her judgment on those who don’t vote. With the rise of Trump and Clinton, this election is a prime example of failed politics. I’ve heard people say they’ll vote for Trump because he’s ‘anti-establishment’ and because he does and says things that are unlike typical politicians. And I’ve heard people say they’ll vote for Clinton because she’s not Trump. Either way, both candidates are a product of the system. Clinton is crooked. And so is Trump. By the election results, no one is going to be happy. We need a government which reflects the people – and this clearly isn’t happening.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s